They played warring New York City high-schoolers in 1999’s fabulously venomous teen drama Cruel Intentions, but Reese Witherspoon, Sarah Michelle Gellar and Selma Blair proved that life doesn’t always reflect art when they enjoyed an unoffical cast reunion in LA last night (May 29).

The trio reunited for the evening to watch an unauthorized musical parody of their hit reworking of literary classic Dangerous Liaisons, 16 years after the release of the original.

Witherspoon summed up our jealous gal pal fury best, sharing a snap of the reunion on Twitter with the caption “Best girls night of the year!!!”

Sarah Michelle Gellar, who played coke-addled Kathryn Merteuil, also shared a snap, congratulating the cast of the musical on an “amazing show”.

And in perhaps the most incredible thing to come out of an already wish-fulling evening, a video emerged of the girls singing along to a rendition of Natalie Imbruglia’s Torn, with Reese showing some serious commitment to the number.

We await the inevitable cast reunion of direct-to-video sequels Cruel Intentions 2: Manchester Prep and Cruel Intentions 3 with equal eagerness.

More stories:
Are two male ‘Bachelorette’ contestants hooking up?
Stereo Kicks’ Barclay Beales bares his bum on Instagram